Connect with us

Crime

When is true crime content inappropriate? Fans, a legal expert and a psychologist speak out

Published

on

Real crime is a phenomenon. From TV shows and movies to podcasts and publications, stories revealing the small print of true crimes, especially missing individuals and murder cases, are considered one of the fastest growing genres. Some people imagine that watching or listening to true crime stories provides a possibility to learn concerning the successes and failures of our criminal justice system, increases awareness of little-known cases, and potentially helps exonerate wrongfully convicted people. Others are critical and say that true crime content can distort the best way we expect concerning the justice system, perpetuate myths about typical victims of violent crimes, or persuade viewers that their online investigations may help solve the case.

When is true crime content inappropriate?  Fans, a legal expert and a psychologist speak out

“I feel crime podcasts, at the least the great ones, provide insight into human nature. In a way, it’s unbelievable that folks can do the things which might be described,” director Norris Francois Jr. tells ESSENCE.

The self-proclaimed podcast enthusiast claims to have listened to tens of 1000’s of hours of podcasts, including crime-related ones. He understands each praise and criticism towards them.

“Some people just tell a story. Some of them end up advocating for specific cases, telling them to look into it, donate to support funds, and get lawyers for people who may be wrongly convicted. So I’m learning a lot in this respect,” says Francois. “But I agree that there are negative aspects overall. I listen to a good range and in some of them you can really hear the tone is exploitative,” he added, noting that these are sometimes the most well-liked true crime podcasts.

Critics of the content say it might desensitize viewers to violent crimes and murders to the purpose that the stories are viewed simply as “entertainment” relatively than real-life tragedies. This is especially true for missing and murdered Black people.

“We know from the data that this is the case [Black women] underrepresented, and when they are represented, sometimes it’s victim blaming, so we ask, you know, why did she come home with so-and-so? Or why they were out at that time of day,” says Dr. Apryl Alexander, associate professor at Department of Public Health Sciences at UNC Charlotte.

The death of Lauren Smith-Fields in December last 12 months received wide media coverage only weeks after her death. Smith-Fields, a 23-year-old black woman, was found dead in her Connecticut apartment after dating an older white man she met on the dating app Bumble. As her story gained national attention, concerns were raised concerning the way it was portrayed within the press, the police investigation and a number of the online reactions via true crime projects.

Some social media users expressed displeasure about her dating outside her race, while others suggested she was involved in prostitution and thus brought violence upon herself. The popularity of a true crime story can influence how comfortable people feel recounting the tragic details and attempting to piece together the story themselves.

“It’s like a lot of victim-blaming content. Instead of “Let’s focus on the terrible event” instead of “Let’s focus on finding the person who caused the harm.” So black women and girls are just not treated equally in some of these cases, generally speaking, and in real crimes as well,” explains Dr. Alexander.

**

In 2003–2004, serial killer Larry Bright lured and murdered at the least eight black women in Peoria, Illinois. Some women were strangled and their bodies dumped in rural areas, others he burned and buried in his yard.

Pinnacle book from 2010 tells the story of Bright and his crimes against women – and it upset a lot of their families. The cover of the book depicts the murderer, and inside there are photographs of assorted crime scenes and artifacts of the murder, similar to bone fragments from a number of the victims.

As writer Terrion L. Williamson draws attention in a 2021 article, the murder investigation book included information that was not available to family and community members. Terrion wrote, “the book sparked a sense of betrayal and outrage in the community because very few family members of the victims had even heard of or spoken to the author before its release.”

Williamson, an associate professor of African American and African American studies on the University of Minnesota, added that Carmea Erving, the eldest daughter of Brenda Erving, the last woman killed by Bright, told her: “It’s not right. How do you understand I need you to inform my story?”

***

From 2018 to 2021, the variety of documentary series on streaming services increased by 63 percent According to data from a media monitoring company, true crime was the most important segment Parrot analytics. Additionally, the common true crime consumer tunes in inside one 12 months estimated to be roughly 84 episodes of true crime shows, 44 chapters of true crime books, 34 episodes of true crime podcasts, and 20 true crime movies survey conducted by Super Summary. The interest is only growing.

As a clinical and forensic psychologist, Dr. Alexander says the rise of the true crime genre is a combination of individuals’s fascination with criminal behavior and its causes, combined with the convenience of access to those stories online through streaming services and social media. In her opinion, nevertheless, it ought to be remembered that this content can’t be viewed just for “entertainment” purposes, but in addition to discuss real events involving real victims.

“I always think about people who say, ‘Oh, I’m obsessed with studying serial killers and finding out everything about them.’ “I at all times say they’d real victims, victims who might have been your friend, member of the family, anyone,” he says.

In September, Netflix released a series about serial killer Jeffrey Dahmer. Between 1978 and 1991, Dahmer murdered and dismembered 17 men and boys, most of whom were LGBT, black or brown. The series broke Netflix’s world record for a series debut in its opening week, nevertheless it also faced heavy backlash, primarily accusing it of cashing in on the trauma experienced by the various black and queer people Dahmer murdered and the families they left behind. .

“We are all one traumatic event away from having the worst day of our lives when you are reduced to your neighbor’s favorite drinking show,” said Eric Perry, a relative of Dahmer victim Errol Lindsey. . “Most importantly, if you’re going to create something that uses real-world people and experiences, you should at least reach out to those people out of respect,” he also said.

Lindsey’s sister, Rita Isbell, whose courtroom victim impact statement was featured on the series, also criticized streaming platform for failing to contact victims’ families before creating program content based on their pain.

When is true crime content inappropriate?  Fans, a legal expert and a psychologist speak out
A still of actress DaShawn Barnes playing Rita Isbell in a courtroom scene from “Monster: The Jeffrey Dahmer Story.” Isbell’s brother, Errol Lindsey, was considered one of the boys Dahmer murdered.

Civil and criminal defense lawyer Sue-Ann Robinson says true crime content and fans of those shows may help or hinder legal investigations. “I feel true crime shows, depending on how they’re made, can provide more information to society. Or they will actually desensitize the general public if it’s done simply for shock value,” said Robinson, who was a legal expert on the first and second seasons of the STARZ investigative docuseries .

As a member of the team, Robinson re-investigated cases through which incarcerated defendants insisted on their innocence. Notably, two of the accused within the series were released from prison based on latest evidence revealed within the serial investigation.

“True Crime fans could be a shield and a sword because in the event that they do the fitting thing, ask the fitting questions and bring attention to a case that does not shine a light on it, then that is great. But in the event that they do negative things, similar to spreading false information or distracting police from things they really want to analyze, then there’s a problem,” Robinson explains.

When is true crime content inappropriate?  Fans, a legal expert and a psychologist speak out
A still of legal expert Sue-Ann Robinson from the STARZ docuseries “Wrong Man.”

True crime fan Morgan Angelique Owens says she watches shows she likes because they deal with the stories of the victims and their families, not the perpetrator.

“What interested me was that I was studying criminology. Growing up in the inner city, I always wanted to go to law school and see how I could make a difference, especially in the criminal justice field,” she shares with . “Actually, my dad was Hamilton County Coroner when I was in college. I had the opportunity to intern in his office and it was an interesting experience that made me even more involved. He actually appeared in a few episodes here in Cincinnati,” he adds.

For Owens, now a media entrepreneur, fact-based content is a very important tool for shedding light on little-known issues, which she says is especially essential in relation to stories about missing and murdered black women who don’t at all times get the eye they deserve .

“The lives of people, especially Black women, who have gone missing or had crimes committed against them, these stories need to be told despite criticism because how will we learn about them and how will we remember them?” says Owens.

She notes that she doesn’t remember seeing the last episode of her favorite crime series that highlighted the stories of black women. Robinson says this often happens because black women are rarely seen as victims of crime. Therefore, the defense attorney and former prosecutor imagine it is vital to vary this perception.

“I think black women are like the canary in the coal mine when it comes to these issues. We are at the intersection of race and gender. So we are the most vulnerable, but we are also the ones on the front line in terms of needing visibility and that is why we need to be more aware of our issues because we are at the crossroads,” Robinson said.

“The more we can have stories that explain our vulnerability, the fact that we are canaries in the coal mine, the fact that this is not a black woman, missing or murdered case, but a missing or murdered person and that it should be a problem for everyone,” she says.

This article was originally published on : www.essence.com
Continue Reading
Advertisement
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Crime

Prosecutors say Sean “Diddy” Combs is trying to obstruct justice by heading to prison

Published

on

By

Sean Combs, Sean "Diddy" Combs. Diddy, Diddy trial, Diddy allegations, Sean Combs trial, Sean Combs allegations, Sean Combs kids, Sean Combs children, Diddy

NEW YORK (AP) — Sean “Diddy” Combs was trying to reach potential witnesses and influence public opinion while in prison in a bid to influence potential jurors in an upcoming sex trafficking trial, prosecutors said in a court filing during which they urged a judge to deny his latest bail request.

The government charges were filed Friday evening in federal court in Manhattan, which opposed the music mogul’s latest offer of $50 million bail. A bail hearing is scheduled for next week.

Prosecutors wrote that a review of recorded phone calls Combs made while in prison shows that he asked relations to contact potential victims and witnesses and urged them to create a “narrative” to influence the jury pool. They say he also encouraged the use of promoting strategies to influence public opinion.

“The defendant has demonstrated time and time again – even while in custody – that he’ll flagrantly and repeatedly disregard the foundations so as to improperly influence the consequence of his case. In other words, the defendant has demonstrated that he can’t be trusted to abide by the terms and conditions,” prosecutors wrote in a press release containing redactions.

Prosecutors wrote that from his behavior it might be inferred that Combs wanted to blackmail victims and witnesses into remaining silent or providing testimony helpful to his defense.

Combs’ lawyers didn’t immediately respond to requests for comment.

Whoopi Goldberg says she can't afford to take a break from work

Prosecutors said Combs, 55, began breaking the foundations almost immediately after being taken into custody Metropolitan Prison Center in Brooklyn after his September arrest.

He pleaded not guilty to the costs brought against him he abused and molested women for years with the assistance of a network of collaborators and employees, while silencing victims through blackmail and violence, including kidnapping, arson and physical beatings.

Two judges found he was a danger to the community and a flight risk.

His lawyers recently filed a 3rd bail application after rejecting two previous attempts, including a $50 million bail offer.

In their motion, they cited modified circumstances, including latest evidence, that they believed justified Combs’ release so he could higher prepare for his May 5 trial.

However, prosecutors said defense lawyers created the most recent bail proposal based on evidence provided to them by prosecutors, and the brand new material was already known to defense lawyers after they submitted previous bail applications.

In their presentation to the judge, prosecutors said Combs’ behavior in prison shows he must remain locked up.

Mary J. Blige and Giuseppe Zanotti announce a new release from their boot collaboration

For example, they said, Combs asked relations to plan and execute a social media campaign around his birthday “with the intent of influencing a potential jury in this criminal proceeding.”

He encouraged his children to post a video on their social media accounts of them gathering to have a good time his birthday, he added.

He then monitored statistics on the jail, including audience engagement, and “explicitly discussed with the family how to ensure the film would have the desired impact on potential jury members in this case,” they said.

The government also alleged that Combs made clear in other conversations that he intended to anonymously publish information that he believed would help him defend against the costs.

“Defendant’s efforts to impede the fairness of these proceedings also include his persistent efforts to contact potential witnesses, including victims of violence, who could provide strong testimony against him,” prosecutors wrote.

This article was originally published on : thegrio.com
Continue Reading

Crime

Celebrity chef and former NFL player Tobias Dorzon is recovering from a shooting attack

Published

on

By

Tobias Dorzon, Tobias Dorzon shooting, Chef Tobias, Black celebrity chefs, theGrio.com

Celebrity chef and former NFL player Tobias Dorzon is recovering after being shot during an alleged robbery.

The shooting occurred on the evening of Tuesday, November 5 in Hyattsville, Maryland, when multiple suspects attempted to rob a man and woman who had just returned from dinner, based on statement from the Hyattsville Police Department.

Police said the victims were taken to hospital with non-life-threatening injuries. Although authorities didn’t initially discover the victims, local council member Wanika Fisher revealed that Dorzon was amongst those attacked.

“I am disheartened and saddened by the news that Prince George’s County restaurant owner Tobias Dorzon was one of two people shot during an attempted robbery Tuesday evening in my neighborhood,” Fisher began in a news release.

She added that Dorzon, a Riverdale native, owns two “amazing” restaurants in Hyattsville and is considered a “dear” friend of hers.

“Such a terrible act could not have happened to a better person,” Fisher continued within the statement. “I offer my sincere condolences to him and the other victim, as well as their families and friends, and wish them both a speedy recovery. This type of senseless violence has no place in our county and county.”

A short and absurd (but true) list of things I'd rather do than get slapped by Mike Tyson

According to Fisher, Dorzon is an “extremely talented” chef who has represented Prince George’s County on the national stage and appeared on several Food Network shows. Most recently, the 39-year-old chef participated within the Food Network’s “Last Bite Hotel,” where he made it to the ultimate 4. He also hosts “Time Out with Tobias” on ESPN.

Off-screen, Dorzon currently owns and manages a company Huncho’s house and exclusive 1123 By Chef Tobias. This spring, he was named Maryland Chef of the Year, the primary honor for somebody from Prince George’s County. In 2021 helped James Harden open his restaurant Thirteen in Houston.

Before becoming a master chef, the Maryland native played within the NFL for each the Tampa Bay Buccaneers and the Tennessee Titans. He also had a stint playing for the Winnipeg Blue Bombers of the Canadian Football League.

How two black entrepreneurs defy the odds in Philadelphia by opening a bacon restaurant

Every week after the shooting, Dorzon updated followers Instagram on his progress.

“I’m still here, thank you all for your prayers. See you soon…. Huncho,” he wrote within the caption of a post that included a screenshot of a tweet during which he admitted that, all things considered, he should be “God’s favorite.”


This article was originally published on : thegrio.com
Continue Reading

Crime

US bans airlines from flying to Haiti and UN suspends flights after gangs shot up planes

Published

on

By

Haiti, Haiti Violence, Haitian gangs, flying to Haiti, gang violence in Haiti, Haitian travel suspended, flights to Haiti suspended, Haitian Prime Minister, Haiti

PORT-AU-PRINCE, Haiti (AP) – The Federal Aviation Administration has banned U.S. airlines from flying to Haiti for 30 days after gangs shot three planes and the United Nations also temporarily suspended flights to Port-au-Prince on Tuesday, limiting humanitarian aid flowing into the country.

On Monday, bullets hit a Spirit Airlines plane that was about to land within the capital, injuring a flight attendant and forcing the airport to close. Photos and videos obtained by The Associated Press show bullet holes scattered throughout the plane’s interior.

On Tuesday, JetBlue and American Airlines announced that post-flight inspections showed their planes were also shot down on Monday while departing Port-au-Prince. The American suspended flights to the capital until February 12.

The shootings were a part of a wave of violence that erupted because the country tormented by gang violence swore in a brand new prime minister after a politically turbulent process.

U.N. spokesman Stephane Dujarric said the agency documented 20 armed clashes and more roadblocks affecting humanitarian operations during Monday’s violence. Port-au-Prince airport will remain closed until November 18, and Dujarric said the United Nations will redirect flights to the country’s second airport, within the northern, quieter city of Cap Haïtien.

Difficult access to the epicenter of violence, Port-au-Prince, is probably going to be devastating as gangs choke life within the capital pushed Haiti to the brink of famine. Dujarric warned that cutting off flights would mean “reducing the flow of humanitarian aid and humanitarian personnel into the country.”

A convoy of 20 trucks full of food and medical supplies has already been rescheduled south, and an operation to provide money assistance to 1,000 people within the Carrefour area, where violence broke out, had to be called off.

“We are doing everything we can to ensure business continuity in this difficult environment,” he said. “We call for an end to the escalation of violence to allow safe, sustainable and unimpeded humanitarian access.”

Life in much of Haiti’s capital got here to a standstill on Tuesday after a wave of violence. Heavily armed police in armored cars checked passing public transport trucks outside the airport.

Schools were closed, as were banks and government offices. The streets, where just the day before there had been a fierce shootout with gangs and police, were eerily empty, with few people passing by apart from motorcycles with a shot man hanging on behind.

In the afternoon, the sounds of heavy gunfire continued to echo through the streets – a reminder that despite political maneuvering by Haiti’s elites and a robust push from the international community to restore peace, the country’s toxic gang group retained a robust grip on many of the Caribbean nation.

The United Nations estimates that gangs control 85% of the capital Port-au-Prince. UN supported mission run by Kenyan police to quell gang violence, scuffling with an absence of funding and staff that prompted the calls for the UN peacekeeping mission.

President Luis Abinader within the Dominican Republic, which borders Haiti, was the primary leader on the island to condemn the violence, labeling the shooting an “act of terrorism.”

On Tuesday, the transitional council established in April to restore democratic order in Haiti also condemned the violence.

“This cowardly crime, which threatens Haiti’s sovereignty and security, goals to isolate our country on the international stage. The perpetrators of those heinous acts shall be tracked down and brought to justice,” the council said in a press release.

The council has faced fierce criticism from many in Haiti who say its political struggles and corruption charges against three members has created political instability, allowing gangs to violently seize power, as happened on Monday.

This happened on the weekend when the primary shot was fired interim Prime Minister Garry Conille – he argued with the Council for a very long time. They replaced him with businessman Alix Didier Fils-Aimé, who was inaugurated on Monday surrounded by suit-wearing officials and diplomats as gangs terrorized the encompassing capital.

Neither Fils-Aimé nor Conille commented on the wave of violence.

Conille initially called the council’s move illegal, but on Tuesday he confirmed Fils-Aimé’s appointment in a post on the X social media platform.

“(I) wish him success in fulfilling this mission. At this crucial moment, unity and solidarity are essential for our country. Long live Haiti!” he wrote. Fils-Aimé promised to work with international partners to restore peace and hold long-awaited elections, a promise also made by his predecessor.

Haiti is changing its prime minister, which means more confusion in the democratic transition

But many Haitians, like 43-year-old Martha Jean-Pierre, don’t have any taste for political fighting, which experts say only gives gangs more freedom to further expand their control.

Jean-Pierre was amongst those that braved the streets of Port-au-Prince on Tuesday to sell bananas, carrots, cabbage and potatoes, which she carried in a basket on her head. She said she had no alternative – selling was the one way she could feed her children.

“What good is a new prime minister if there is no security, if I cannot move freely and sell my goods?” she said, nodding at her basket of vegetables. “This is my bank account. My family depends on it.”

The frustration alarmed international actors comparable to the UN and the US, who called for a peaceful resolution to the situation in Haiti.

On Tuesday, the US State Department regretted that Conille and the Council had been “unable to make progress in a constructive manner” and called on Fils-Aimé and the Council to present a transparent plan of motion with a shared vision to reduce violence and pave the way in which for an electoral path that is meant to “prevent further deadlock.”

“The urgent and immediate needs of the Haitian people compel the interim government to prioritize governance over the competing personal interests of political actors,” the statement said.

This article was originally published on : thegrio.com
Continue Reading
Advertisement

OUR NEWSLETTER

Subscribe Us To Receive Our Latest News Directly In Your Inbox!

We don’t spam! Read our privacy policy for more info.

Trending