Connect with us

International

Map Wars in the Middle East: How cartographers set and helped shape a regional conflict

Published

on

The maps are ubiquitous-for phones, flight and automobile displays and in textbooks around the world. While some maps determine territories and boundaries, others show different blocks of voting in elections, and GPS devices help drivers go to the destination.

But no matter the purpose, all maps have something to do: They are political. The maps involve making decisions about what to disregard and what to have in mind. They are subject to selection, classification, abstraction and simplifications. And studying elections that enter the maps, like meHe can reveal various stories about the land and individuals who consider it their very own.

Nowhere is it more true than in the contested regions that today include contemporary Israel and Palestinian territories. Since the establishment of the State of Israel in 1948, various government and non -governmental organizations and political interests have been involved in what’s best to explain as “Maps of wars. “

Advertisement

The region’s maps use the name of places, the position of borders and the inclusion or omission of some territories to present contrasting geopolitical visions. To today, Israel or Palestinian territories may fall from some maps, depending on the policy of their creators.

This doesn’t apply only to the Middle East – “MAP wars” are ongoing around the world. Some of the more known examples include the disputes between Ukraine and Russia, Taiwan and ChinaAND India and China. Everyone is involved in the controversy regarding the territorial integrity of nation -states.

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu shows the map of Israel indicating that Golan Heights are inside the borders of the state.
Thomas Coex/AFP via Getty Images

Short history of maps

Traditionally, maps were used to represent cosmology, cultures and beliefs. In the seventeenth century, the maps represented spatial relations on a given territory Beaome vital for the creation of national states. Such official maps helped with an attachment of territories and determine property rights. Indeed, mapping territory that’s to know and control it.

Recently, map creation tools have change into more available. Anyone who has access to the computer and the Internet can now create and share “alternative maps” that present various visions of the territory and make a number of geopolitical claims.

Advertisement

And the maps produced in the conflict region, akin to Israel and Palestinian territories, tell a wealthy story about the relationship between map creation and politics.

Middle East mapping

While The British Palestine Mandate in 1917–1947British inspectors mapped territories to manage the ground and its people. It was an attempt to interchange more informal claims from the Ottoman land of those times.

By Establishment of Israel in 1948IN Only about 20% of the total area of ​​what’s often known as historical Palestine – The undeniable fact that he still fueled disputes about the earth today. The British efforts of mapping and their omission enabled the newly established state of Israel to acknowledge most territories as state lands, thus delegitimizing claims from the Palestinian region.

The black and white map shows various shady areas, some of the
The map shows the shaded areas of the Arab state beneficial by the Special UN Committee for Palestine in 1947. Unparalleled areas are parts of the proposed Jewish state.
Archives Underwood/Getty Images

The maps also helped construct an Israeli state. Surveyors and planners mapped the land to assign land rights and helped construct state infrastructure, including roads and railways.

But the maps also helped to create a sense of nationality. Maps representing the shape of the nation by sketching its national borders are often known as Maps “Logo”. They can increase the sense of national unity and a sense of national belonging.

Advertisement

After establishing, the Israeli state converted the maps of the region. The Israeli government commission invented Hebrew names, which previously replaced Arab and Christian names for various cities and villages on the official map of Israel. At the same time, there have been previously Palestinian topographs and places omitted from the map.

However, some Palestinian map creators still create maps, including the Palestinian named and present the historical Palestine before 1948-which extends from the Jordan River in the East to the Mediterranean in the West. Such maps are used to support the right of Palestinians for landing and supporting the sense of national affiliation.

A woman in a headlamp keeps her head support the map
The Palestinian woman holds a map of the British Palestine mandate during a protest in the city of Gaza on February 27, 2020.
Mohammed Abed/AFP via Getty Images

At the same time, Palestinian cartographers who work with Palestinian authority – The government body, which manages partial civil control over Palestinian enclaves on the west shore – creates official maps of the West Brzeg and Gaza in the hope of creating the future state of Palestine. They adapt their maps to UN efforts to map territories in accordance with international law by winning the West Bank and Gaza as separate from Israel.

After In 1967, the war between Israel and his Arab neighborsIsrael occupied the west and gauze. As a results of the wars of the map, he intensified, especially between different fractions in Israel. The leftist “peace camp”, which was dedicated to territorial compromises with Palestinians, was directed against the Israeli right -wing wing involved in the recovery of the “promised land” for ensuring the security of Israel.

Such incompatible geopolitical visions are still reflected in produced maps. The maps of the “peace camp” adhere to the designation of territories in accordance with international law. For example, they include a green line – a recognized international weapon line between the western shore and Israel. Official maps produced by the Israeli government, while, He stopped setting a green line after 1967.

Advertisement

Wider and border disputes

Various interest groups and political actors not only used the region’s maps to make competitive geopolitical claims, but the maps also played a key role in sporadic efforts to ascertain peace in the region.

. 1993 Oslo contractsThe goal was that after a five -year temporary period, a everlasting peace settlement was negotiated based on the boundaries set out on these maps.

Map with some areas highlighted in yellow.
Map of West Brzeg with proposed areas controlled by Palestine in yellow, in accordance with Oslo II agreements.
Wikimedia Commons

Consequently, Palestinian planners and surveyors he mapped the territory Assigned to the future state of Palestine. Due to the undeniable fact that Oslo guarantees only the future state – but with its borders and the level of sovereignty still uncertain – Palestinian experts are still preparing for the ruling territories by mapping them.

Oslo maps are still used today to stipulate the geopolitical visions of Israel and the future state of Palestine based on international law. But for a lot of Israelis, the vision of Oslo The two -state solution has died – The attack of Hamas, a Palestinian nationalist political organization, which rules gauze, on Israel on October 7, 2023, was his last blow.

Another war between Israel and Hamas, currently being suspended by weapons, from the very starting was related to the maps.

Advertisement

In December 2023, the Israeli army published an internet “Map of evacuation”, which divided the Gaza belt into 623 zones. Palestinians can go to online mode – provided that they’ve access to electricity and the Internet on the territory harassed by browning – to search out out if their area has been called to evacuate. Israeli military commanders I used this map Decide where to shoot raids and perform ground maneuvers.

But the map also served the political goal: to persuade the skeptical world Israel took care of protect civilians. Regardless, its introduction caused it Confusion and fear amongst Palestinians.

Determining the road forward

Maps usually are not only to grasp the past and present – they assist people also imagine the future. Different maps can reveal conflicting geopolitical visions.

For example, in January 2024 Israel’s victory conference. The goal was to plan the resettlement of Gaza and increase Jewish settlements on the west bank. The speakers were in favor of transferring Palestinians from the belt to Sinai through “voluntary emigration”. Because Jewish settlers plan to return to Gaza, and the speakers cite each the safety of the Bible and Israel on justification, the oversized map showed the location of the proposed Jewish settlements.

Advertisement
A man with a cell phone stands in front of a large green map.
The man takes a photo with a map showing the Gaza Strip with Jewish settlements during the convention calling on Strip Gaza on January 28, 2024 in Jerusalem, Israel.
Paintings Amir Levy/Getty

Similarly, the Israeli Movement for the settlement in Southern Lebanon published Maps of planned Jewish settlements in southern Lebanon.

Such maps reveal the desire for some in Israel for “Larger Israel“-Inzar described in 1904 by Theodor Herzl, considered the father of up to date Zionism, as the stream of Egypt to the Euphrate.

No wonder that Palestinians make different maps to assume the future. Flast appearing – Palestinian and international initiative, which mixes various experts, organizations and founders – uses maps connecting gauze with the west bank and a wider region.

The blue map shows various transport nodes.
The map shows the proposed link to the transport of the Gaza-West bank corridor.
Flast appearing

Their goal is to rework gauze in Commercial Hub for Trade, Tourism and Innovation and integrate it with the global economy. Therefore, maps of urban projects, airports and seaports overlap the cartographic contours of Gaza; and the corridor of Bank Gaza-West, which could be sealed for Israeli security, can connect two geographically separate Palestinian territories.

Such maps reflect the efforts of Palestinian stakeholders in order to further study territories, which since the agreement in Oslo were to be the future state of Palestine.

A brand new era of expansion geopolitics

With the current US administration more adapted to the right -wing Israeli policyMaps of a larger Israel can lead what Hagit ofran from Room now calls the starting of the latest “Larger Israel“Politics period.

Advertisement

Seemingly increasing US rule, a long -term policy of supporting a two -state solution in which Gaza could be a part of the Palestinian state, Donald Trump on February 4, 2025. He raised a plan for the United States to “take over” gauzeby leading their current residents and transforming the enclave into “” Riviera Middle East “.

Such a move could be one other try to convert borders in the Middle East. However, this is able to not end the “map of the map” in Israel/Palestine.

Advertisement
This article was originally published on : theconversation.com
Continue Reading
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

International

Egypt on the edge: Finding a delicate balance between Gaza and Trump

Published

on

By


How does Egypt dependent on the USA?

With time, Egypt received more American foreign help than any country except Israel. Received USD 78 billion for economic assistance and USD 90 billion From 1946.

AND peace agreement In 1979, he ended the war between two countries with Israel. Israeli forces withdrew from the Egyptian Sinai Peninsula. Since then, the US has provided Egypt with a everlasting amount USD 1.5 billion, of which USD 1.3 billion is military assistanceEvery 12 months. Goes to financing the purchase by Egyptian weapons systems from American defense contractors.

Help in the US has been the cornerstone of Egyptian and USA for a long time.

Advertisement

Since 1979, Egypt has been a central pillar of American policy in the Middle East. Military assistance is taken into account essential for the regime in Egypt to adapt to the US interests. At the same time, this assistance is widely perceived as contributing to survival Egyptian authoritarian regime.

But history shows that Egypt can alleviate the potential impact of assist in the US in periods of stressed relationships.

USA He suspended some military help to Egypt after Change in the regime in 2013. At that point, El-Sisi who was Selected president in 2014He received support from Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates. He too Increased weapons import from France and Russia.

After the period of review, the Barack Obama administration published Egypt to preserve the interests of the USA. As US Secretary of State John Kerry once explained:

Advertisement

We receive a refund from this investment, which shouldn’t be irrelevant. The army also helps us to implement safety in Sinai (in Egypt). The army also helps us to implement a room in gas.

If this relationship becomes burdened again, Egypt may learn much more independent. The influence of China in Egypt is developmentAnd the Persia of the Persian Gulf, which enjoy close relations with Sisi, can even resolve to finance.

How did Egypt balance his interests with Arab countries, Israel and the USA?

Signature Egyptian-Israeli Peace Treaty in 1979 A change in Egyptian foreign policy was marked. The treaty adapted Egypt with the West in the recognition of Israel. This decision, nonetheless, led to the isolation of Egypt in the Arab world and its exclusion from Arab league (This was again adopted in 1989).

When Mohamed Hosni Mubarak It was assumed that power The murder of Anwar El-Sadata in 1981Egypt needed to balance the US partnership, keep peace with Israel and reconcile his relations with the Arab countries.

Egypt condemned Israel’s aggression against Palestinians and against Lebanon in 1982 and 2006 and freeze efforts to normalize relations with Israel. This strengthened its key position in Arab circles without exposing the room with Israel.

Advertisement

Meanwhile, Egypt has helped American military assets in moving through the region, and the oil sailed through the SUEZ channel. He maintained peace and stability with Israel by pressure Palestinian resistance movements in de -escation. This balance act allowed Egypt to change into a mediator between Palestine and Israel.

Egypt under Sisi tried to keep up the balance act. However, the ongoing war in Gaza was intensified by Egypt challenges. These include flights for refugees and instability on its border. The war also threatened the long role of Egypt in the Middle East region.

How did the war in Gaza threatened the act of balance of Egypt?

The starting of the war in Gaza in October 2023 was on the fringe of Egypt. Kair is afraid of the potential strategy of Israel consisting in the forced location of Palestinians on the Sinai Peninsula, which is positioned on its territory. Egyptian officials recognized this scenario as Red line. Kair doesn’t need to be seen as undermining the Palestinian case.

In addition, the Egyptians are afraid that the presence of a significant Palestinian population in Sinai – which connects Africa with Asia, and borders with Israel and Gaza – can transform the region into a region into a region into a region Launchpad for attacks About Israel. This would force Egypt to suppress such activities or retaliation from Israel.

Advertisement

This fear results from Incident from 1955. The Israeli army attacked the Egyptian military camp in the Gaza Strip, which was then subject to Egyptian control. Seventeen soldiers were killed after the Palestinian Izrael fighter killed. The Palestinian transfer plan to Sinai caused protests in the Gaza Strip, bringing the Egyptian army in a direct confrontation with Palestinians.

This historical event still shapes Egyptian foreign policy, which rejects all the transfer of Palestinians to Sinai.

The current war emphasized structural weaknesses in A certain Egyptian economy. Houthi attacks in the Red Sea, which began in 2024 sharp drop In revenues from the Suez Canal, a critical source of foreign income for Egypt.

Sisi played in European fears that what happened in Gaza could harm Egypt’s economic situation and result in it Mass migration to Europe. But money infusions won’t solve deeply rooted economic challenges that the country faces.

Advertisement

The role of Cairo as a mediator between the West, Israel and the Arab world faces the renovated challenges. Other mediators Rhinitisappeared.

What can affect Egypt’s response to Trump’s proposal to the transfer of Palestinians?

Trump application He places the Egyptian regime in an uncertain position. If Egypt agrees to the Palestinian transfer plan, it will mean a dramatic departure from basic foreign policy. It can even destroy the dissatisfaction between his population.

Rejection of proposals would charge Egypt’s relations, potentially undermining support for the SISI regime, which can then be trying to find help from other countries.

The conflict in Gaza emphasizes the historical and political entanglement of Egypt in the Palestinian issue.

Advertisement

This article was originally published on : theconversation.com
Continue Reading

International

Abu Mohammed Al-Golani can become the face of Syria post-assad-but who he is and why has 10 million USD prizes on his head?

Published

on

By

What is Hayat Tahrir Al-Sham?

Hayat Tahrir al-Sham has its roots In the early stages of the civil war in Syria, which began in 2011 as a preferred rebellion against the autocratic government of Assad.

The group was created As a branch of the Nusra Front, the official Al-Qaeda Association in Syria. Hayat Tahrir Al-Sham was initially recognized as the effectiveness of the fight and commitment to the global ideology of jihadists or the establishment of strict Islamic rule throughout the Muslim world.

Advertisement

For a change in 2016, Nusra Front publicly cut ties with al-Qaeda And he adopted the recent name Jabhat Fateh al-Sham, which implies “front for the conquest of the left.”

The following yr, it merged with several other factions in the Syrian War to become Hayat Tahrir Al-Sham or “Organization of Lewant’s liberation.”

This rebranding was geared toward moving away from the global al-Qaeda jihadist program, which limited the group’s appeal in Syria. Allowed Hayat Tahrir al-Sham Focus on issues Specific for Syrians, equivalent to local management, economic issues and humanitarian aid.

Despite these changes, the basic ideology of Hayat Tahrira Al-Sham is still rooted in jihadism, with the foremost purpose of overthrowing the Assad government and establishing Islamic rule in Syria.

Advertisement

Who is al-Golani? How does the group’s central success have?

Abu Mohammed al-Golani Born Ahmed Al-Sharaa In 1982 in Saudi Arabia.

Al-Golani spent early years in Damascus, Syria after his family returned from Saudi Arabia in 1989. His profession of jihadists began in Iraq, where he joined the fighters compatible with Al-Qaeda later The invasion of the USA in 2003.

In 2011, under the direction of an Iraqi fighter, and then-al-Qaeda at Iraq’s leader Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi, Al-Golani was designed to establish a front of the Nusra in Syria.

The group quickly became a robust force in the civil war in Syria.

Advertisement

This is under the leadership of al-Golani Hayat Tahrir al-Sham He tried to introduce As pragmatic, less focused on global jihada, and more on issues related to management in the Idlib region, the largest rebel fortress in Syria.

This change of strategy is part of Al-Golani’s efforts to remodel his national and global image because of the jihadist leader right into a more politically profitable figure in Syrian policy.

The shift of Al-Golani towards a more pragmatic approach, especially after 2017, was crucial for the help of Hayat Tahrir Al-Sham Territories and providing itself as a regional ruling force. His last moves, equivalent to adoption more moderate Persona and engaging in traditional public service reflect the central role of Al-Golani in the army and the political evolution of Hayat Tahrir Al-Sham-extinguishing the group of power and its efforts in obtaining ID card and international ID.

The Syrians have fun the armed groups led by Hayat Tahrira Al-Sham by President Bashar al-Assad.
Omer Alven/Anadol via Getty Images

How did the group become the foremost force in Syria?

To maintain power over controlled territories, Hayat Tahrir Al-Sham used a method mix including the establishment of management systems that might ensure stability and services, while legitimizing their control in the eyes of local population.

Advertisement

Aiming to expand and take a bigger territory, the group’s leaders got here to the conclusion required To gain a global community to reduce international opposition and effectively cooperate with a broader Syrian revolutionary movement.

This included cooperation with other entities in Syria, geared toward presenting a united front, which can be more tasty for international observers and potential allies. To do that locally, hayat tahrir al-sham brought many Groups in Syria under his control. Regional and international transformed his image through public relations campaigns, equivalent to engaging in social services.

Hayat Tahrir al-Sham was since 2017 dominant strength in IdlibWhich, after the government forces, gained control over Aleppo in December 2016, became the last necessary bastion for various groups of rebels.

Over the years, the group has recorded control in the region by functioning as a quasi-eNmutmentProvision of civil services and supervision Local matters – equivalent to controlling motorways and collecting obligations in the field of transport transport – Despite the reports human rights violations.

Advertisement

In recent years, propaganda Hayat Tahrir al-Sham emphasized Protection of Syrian territory and his people against the Assad government.

It helped the group strengthen your position amongst local communities and other rebel groups.

Trying to proceed to burn his image, Hayat Tahrir Al-Sham increased public relations efforts, each at home and abroad. For example, he has involved with international media and humanitarian organizations to barter – and filming – help supplies to the areas that rules.

Hayat Tahrir al-sham helped Get local supportpositioning as a defender of Sunni Muslim interests.

Advertisement

Meanwhile, Hayat Tahrir al-Sham strengthened his military abilities Establishing the Military Academy, reorganizing its units in a more conventional military structure and creating specialized forces expert in the performance of coordinated and strategic attacks. The recent advance seems proof that this strategy has paid off.

What does the USA take into consideration the group and al-Golani?

The USA has long Listed al-golani As a specially designated global terrorist and Nusra front as a foreign terrorist organization.

In May 2018, the US Department of State expanded This is a designation covering Hayat Tahrir al-Sham. As a result of these markings, the group and its members encounter legal restrictions, travel bans, freeze assets and banking restrictions.

In addition, the State Department Awards for justice The program is Offering as much as USD 10 million To get details about Al-Golani.

Advertisement

However, the news circled that there have been the United States considering Removing the prize for $ 10 million per leader Hayat Tahrir Al-Sham, while Great Britain is Thinking about deleting the group from the terrorist list.

What happens if Al-Golani appears as a post-assad leader?

First of all, we should always notice that these are very early days and stays unclear what Syria will appear to be.

But based on my years, studying Islamic history and Hayat Tahrir al-Sham, I’m able to risk several educated guesses. Historically, Islamic empires used a transparent management framework to administer their expansion and administration, which can inform about the approach of Hayat Tahrir Al-Sham to reflect these successful strategies.

First of all, I believe Al-Golani probably strives for authentic religious leadership, positioning as a pacesetter whose personal piety and compliance with Islamic principles are according to the religious sentiments of the population.

Advertisement

This can be supplemented by Hayat Tahrir Al-Sham, emphasizing the role of Sunni Islam in state functions in Syria and integrating religious legal practices with national laws.

Similarly to the situated scale, an efficient administration can become the Hayat Tahrir Al-Sham cornerstone. For example, in Idlib, the group established tax systems and community involvement. This is obligatory to construct trust, especially amongst previously marginalized groups.

In addition, allowing some autonomy to have regions in Syria, Hayat Tahrir Al-Sham can alleviate the risk of anxiety, balancing strict Islamic law enforcement agencies with cultural and ethnic diversity in Syria.

In general, if Hayat Tahrir Al-Sham at Al-Golani tried to direct the creation of a brand new Syria government, we can expect a management approach, which goals to mix traditional Islamic management and a contemporary ship, attempting to stabilize and harmonize the various and war of the war.

Advertisement

However, the controversial status of the group and the history of combat operations can be serious challenges in terms of universal recognition of international and internal support.

This article was originally published on : theconversation.com
Advertisement
Continue Reading

International

Hamas – trimmed and isolated – is located in few options as a day after the war in Gaza

Published

on

By

At the starting of December 2024, Hamas announced a serious license: it was prepared for everlasting future management From Gaza to the unity of the Palestinian Committee, working along with his foremost political rival, Fatah, to create a body.

Fatah, party President of Palestinian Autonomy Mahmoud AbbasFrom then on, he expressed hesitation before such an agreement – with which he could be battling Israel’s strict opposition And probably also the USA. . But the proven fact that Hamas would hit such a fraction agreement He took the weapon For the right to rule, gauze indicates primarily the weakened position of the combat group after greater than a 12 months of the destructive war of Israel in Gaza.

Last Israel Weapon suspension agreement In Lebanon, he damaged Hamas’s perspectives much more, limiting the direct support of Hezbollah in Gaza, and as for Iran – leaving him much more isolated.

Advertisement

Hamas, trimmed on all pages, from my observations as Palestinian policy expertHe modified the differential account for the world of war after gas. The proven fact that Egypt has pressed the Fatah-Hamas contract is also noteworthy, because what ultimately goes through in terms of gauze management, probably is dependent upon the wishes of the rule in Cairo and Israel, from which each sees gauze as a yard of its national security.

Egyptian plan for Gaza

Egypt, with silent support from the United States, focused on what the future Palestinian political agreement in Gaza could appear like. An try to solve this vacuum of security and management, Egypt he convened leaders Both about Fatah and Hamas traffic in the hope of making a management committee to take over the management of gauze after the war.

In Cairo, Egyptian mediators proposed to determine the Social Support Committee, which consists of Palestinian professionals and technocrat who should not related to Fatah or Hamas. Abbas, who as the leader of the Palestinian authority has the authority of management on the West Bank, is subject to Israeli approval you’ve gotten to verify Committee.

The rapid acceptance of the Egyptian formula by Hamas indicates a group standing in the face of a completely different security and organizational environment than before the escalation of the conflict with Israel.

Advertisement

Moving regional dynamics

When Hamas began his attacks on October 7, 2023, yes, knowing that he could depend on energetic military support from Hesbollah allies in neighboring Lebanon and ongoing financial and diplomatic protection from Iran.

Fast forward 14 months position of the so -called Tehran’s “resistance” looks rather more fragile. Hezbollah and the Israeli months of violence in the Tit-For-Tat along the Israeli-Library border intensified to the full war that Israel saw Expand your brutal military campaign to southern Lebanon. Hezbollah emerged from this fight seriously wounded, having He lost many members His leadership for Israeli bombs.

Another suspension of weapons from November 26 effectively pulled Hezbollah out of the conflict in Gaza.

Meanwhile, Iran, who mentioned the rounds of rocket salvos with Israel, has to date eagerly ordered a direct confrontation with Israel with Hamas and Hezbollah replacements, attempting to avoid long -term military involvement with Israel.

Advertisement

After limiting this regional military support, Hamas also stands in the face of a modified diplomatic landscape.

From 2012, Qatar hosted the political leader of Hamas on the basis of a contract with the United States. Since then, the small nation of the Persian Gulf acted as a mediator between Hamas and Israel and the United States, which refuse to barter with the group directly.

But at the starting of November Qatar He announced that he was hanging His role in mediation in peace conversations in Gaza, citing dissatisfaction with this process, though suggested Conversations may be recovery And that it mediated again.

In any case, American officials have recently forced a runny nose Snapshot of his political office HamasAnd the political agents of Hamas remained there Apparently it expanded to Turkey.

Advertisement

Qatar also looks at the modified American political scene in which they’re the upcoming Republican Congress and President-Elek Donald Trump It probably exerts an excellent tougher line About Hamas having any political base outside of gauze.

Decimated, each military and politically

In addition to growing insulation, Hamas also suffered deep operational damage during the war in Gaza.

The recent Israeli killing of Hamas Yahya Sinwar leader caused a vacuum at the very top. It happened after Israel has already killed most of the higher military and political leadership Hamas in Gaza, not to say well -known political leaders from outside Gaza, such as the political leader Hamas Ismail Haniyeh, which was murdered in July in Iran.

It is not even clear who creates Hamas leadership in Gaza since December 2024, apart from brother Sinwar, Mohammed, who is a member of the Hamas military wing. It is also unclear whether Hamas members may even communicate with leaders.

Advertisement

For now, the outstanding leader of Hamas Khalil Al-Hayya was involved in talks with Fatah in Egypt. However, the executive committee of the Palestinian Liberation Organization – which Fatah is the dominant faction – rejected the Egyptian proposal.

This doesn’t mean that the proposal is necessarily dead in water – only that Egypt may have to cooperate with Fatah leaders to resolve their fears.

Exhausted Eyes’ Movement about the future

While Hamas has been weakened militarily and politically, there is also a little probability that Hamas won’t remain an ideologically strong force, able to attracting the support of many Palestinians in Gaza, as well as on the west shore and a wider Palestinian diaspora.

But as the ruling entity Hamas appears to be a worn force in the foreseeable future – something that members of the group willingly recognize.

Advertisement
Mahmoud al-Aloul, a senior Fatah politician, meets Mussa Abu Marzuk from Hamas during a dialogue organized by China on July 23, 2024.
Pedro Pardo/AFP via Getty Images

Recently Egyptian Palestinian conversations, although efficiently, indicate how every long-term future for Gaza-lub Palestinians as a whole-implies a more coherent Palestinian political leadership.

Indeed, one among the latest Egyptian plans is that it doesn’t connect Palestinians under a unified government, because the proposed ruling being will only be liable for supervising the Gaza belt.

And the trust between Hamas and Fatah stays low, as it has been since then Hamas took over Gaza Strip in June 2007 After a sudden confrontation with Fatah.

However, even when Hamas and Fatah would comply with the government of unityThe wider reality is that it cannot occur as long as Israel and its international allies, mainly the United States, oppose this.

Advertisement

For his part, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has repeatedly stated it Nor Palestinian Neither Hamas play any role day after the war.

When the war was over

However, in addition to the everlasting Israeli military occupation, it is difficult to see what options exist for Palestinians who’re going forward in the event of unification in Palestinian policy.

When Hamas won a serious victory In the Palestinian legislative elections in January 2006 it was largely as a consequence of Fatah divisions, corruption, and widespread dissatisfaction with what was provided by Oslo’s peace process and a small sign of future progress against the Palestinian state.

Almost 20 years later, none of those realities modified significantly.

Advertisement

Gaza devastation only intensified the humanitarian crisis and the difficulty of the long -term chart of the solution. However, when the war in Gaza is over, there will likely be no options for Arab countries, including Egypt, the United States and a wider international community to assist Palestinians to rebuild the enclave in reconstruction and on the lookout for a certain security measure. Palestinians who live there cannot afford one other management of management.

This article was originally published on : theconversation.com
Advertisement
Continue Reading
Advertisement

OUR NEWSLETTER

Subscribe Us To Receive Our Latest News Directly In Your Inbox!

We don’t spam! Read our privacy policy for more info.

Trending