Mariah Carey did not steal “Everything I want at Christmas is you” from other writers, says the judge

The federal judge in Los Angeles said that Mariah Carey did not steal his long -term megahit “All and Want for Christmas is you” from other songs.

Judge Moznica Ramírez Almadani awarded Carey’s request on Wednesday to issue a summary sentence, giving her and co -author and co -accused Walter Afanasuff victory with out a trial.

In 2023, the Kisters of Andy Stone from Louisiana – who passes through the Vince Vance scene – and Troy Powers from Tennessee filed a lawsuit price $ 20 million, claiming that the Carey song from 1994, which since then became a Christmas and annual sensation of streaming, violated the copyright of his country from 1989.

Their lawyer Gerard P. Fox said he was “disappointed” in the mail to the Associated Press.

Fox said that this is his experience of judges at this level “they almost at all times reject the musical case and that it is mandatory to confer with the reversal and referring the jury’s case. My client will soon resolve whether he appealed.

Stone and Powers’ Suit said that “everything I want at Christmas is you” comprises a novel language structure, by which an individual, dissatisfied with expensive presents and seasonal comforts, desires to be with a loved one, and subsequently writes a letter to Santa. “

They said that there was “overwhelming probability” that Carey and Afanasuff heard their song – which at some point reached 31 place for Hot Country Chart – and violated their copyright, taking significant elements from her.

After hearing from two experts on all sides, Ramírez Almadani agreed with people from defense who said that the writers hired a joint Christmas stereotype that existed before each songs, and that Carey’s song used them in another way. She said that the plaintiffs did not meet the burden of showing that the songs were essentially similar.

Ramírez Almadani also ordered sanctions against the plaintiffs and their lawyers, saying that their lawsuit and subsequent subjects were frivolous and that the plaintiff lawyers “did not” make any reasonable efforts to make sure that that actual disputes of evidence of evidence “.

She said that they’d to pay at least a few of the lawyers’ lawyers.

Carey lawyers and journalists did not immediately answer at the request for comment.

Carey’s festive colossus has develop into a fair greater hit in recent times than in the Nineties. In the last six years in a row has reached the no 1 on the Hot 100 Billboard list-what every week measures the hottest songs-not only in the festive theme-with the help of Airplay, Sales and Streaming.

Carey and Afanasuff had their very own public misunderstanding – although not one which went to court – who wrote how much songs. But the case meant that at least temporary allies.